New Testament
Paul corrects Peter to his face at Antioch

The first public correction of a Church leader was one apostle telling another he was being a hypocrite.
When Peter stopped eating with Gentile Christians in Antioch for fear of the circumcision party, Paul "opposed him to his face" in front of everyone (Galatians 2:11–14). Protestants often cite it against papal authority; Catholics answer that it was a failure of conduct, not of teaching, since Peter himself had said at the Jerusalem Council that Gentiles are saved by grace without the Law (Acts 15:7–11). Paul also says he went to Jerusalem to see Peter and stayed with him fifteen days (Galatians 1:18).
People
Did you know
- Paul calls Peter by his Aramaic name, Cephas, 'rock', throughout Galatians.
- Even Barnabas was 'carried away' by the same hypocrisy, Paul says (Galatians 2:13).
- Catholic teaching says popes can sin and err in conduct; infallibility covers only solemn definitions of faith and morals (Vatican I, Pastor Aeternus 4).
Sources
- Galatians 1:18; 2:7–14
- Acts 15:7–11
- Vatican I, Pastor Aeternus ch. 4 (1870)