Legends & Lore
Pope Joan (debunked legend)

The female pope never existed, but she was believed in for four hundred years.
The legend of a woman disguised as a man who became pope and gave birth during a procession first appears in the 13th century, in the chronicle of Jean de Mailly (c. 1250) and in Martin of Opava, who placed her after Leo IV. It is false: Benedict III followed Leo IV within weeks in 855, and coins and documents leave no gap. It was used in polemics during the Reformation, and the Protestant scholar David Blondel refuted it in 1647.
Did you know
- No source written in the 9th, 10th, 11th or 12th century mentions her.
- Coins of Benedict III with the emperor Lothair I (d. 855) close the supposed gap.
- A bust of 'Joan' was reportedly among the popes in Siena Cathedral until about 1600.
Sources
- Martin of Opava, Chronicon pontificum et imperatorum
- David Blondel, Familier esclaircissement de la question si une femme a esté assise au siège papal (1647)
- Catholic Encyclopedia (1913), "Popess Joan"