Miracles
Holy Office: "not proven" supernatural for Padre Pio

Rome's first official word on the stigmata: not proven.
Fr Agostino Gemelli, physician and founder of the Catholic University of Milan, met Padre Pio in 1920 and wrote a hostile assessment without examining the wounds. Bishop Raffaello Carlo Rossi's apostolic visitation in 1921 was favourable. On 31 May 1923 the Holy Office nevertheless declared that it was not established that the phenomena were supernatural (non constare de supernaturalitate) and told the faithful to act accordingly.
People
Did you know
- Rossi's 1921 report stayed secret until it was published in 2008.
- Gemelli never saw the wounds uncovered.
- The decree did not call him a fraud; it withheld a verdict of the supernatural.
Sources
- Acta Apostolicae Sedis 15 (1923), Holy Office declaration of 31 May 1923
- Francesco Castelli, Padre Pio under Investigation: The Secret Vatican Files (2008, Eng. 2011)