scholar
Margherita Guarducci

Life
Margherita Guarducci was born in Florence and became one of the leading Greek epigraphists of the 20th century, editing the four-volume Inscriptiones Creticae. In the 1950s she studied the graffiti on a wall beside the ancient monument found under the high altar of St Peter's during the excavations of 1939–49. She read one fragment as saying, in Greek, that Peter was within, and argued that the wall's many inscribed invocations showed early devotion to Peter at this spot. She also learned that bones from a niche in that graffiti wall had been removed during the excavations and stored separately; anthropological study found them to belong to a single elderly, robust man, with traces of purple cloth with gold thread and soil like that of the original grave. She argued that these were Peter's bones, and in 1968 Paul VI announced that the relics had been identified in a way he judged convincing. Other archaeologists, including members of the original excavation team, disputed her methods and conclusions. She also argued, in 1980, that the famous Praeneste brooch inscription was a modern forgery. She died in Rome in 1999.
Did you know
- She read a graffito under St Peter's as 'Peter is within'.
- The bones she identified had been kept in a box away from the excavators for years.
- She also challenged the authenticity of the Praeneste fibula, a famous early Latin inscription.
- The debate over her identification of Peter's bones continues.
Sources
- Margherita Guarducci, The Tomb of St Peter (1960)
- Margherita Guarducci, Le reliquie di Pietro sotto la Confessione della Basilica Vaticana (1965)
- John Evangelist Walsh, The Bones of St Peter (1982)